I’ve never actually sat down and listened to a Neil Diamond record. I have, however, listened to Me First and the Gimme Gimmes’ covers of his songs, repeatedly. And I am aware he's sold a few records here and there. There might even be some movies about him, too. If I ever frequented a bar there’s a good chance I might even partake in a group sing-along to a tune of his.
So my formal introduction to Mr. Diamond is this 33rd album that was recorded in 2007 and is the final chapter of a trilogy of albums with the legendary producer Rick Rubin.
The title track opens and is a mostly gentle moment of folk-rock ideas, where Heartbreaker Benmont Tench’s frisky keys won’t go unnoticed. “You Can’t Have It All” then follows with a bare approach that allows for Diamond’s voice to soar alongside gentle melodies.
Deeper into Side A the empowering and wise “Shine On” is a heartfelt moment with emphasis on keys, and “The Secret You” enlists fellow Heartbreaker Mike Campbell and Matt Sweeney on guitars which suits Diamond’s rich pipes.
The back half welcomes the fuller and anthemic “You Never Know,” while “You’re Getting To Me” is almost gritty in its emotional delivery. “You’re My Favorite Song” is actually my favorite song here, where melody and rhythm are present and makes it instantly memorable. “Forgotten,” which is a more stripped back version of a tune on another album of Diamond’s, exits and fits the subdued mood of the entire record.
All the tracks are previously unreleased, and further prove that Diamond doesn’t just excel in loud settings. His reflective and philosophical angle is explored via the many love songs present, and it’s pretty safe to say this album is a late-career highlight for this American treasure.